Back to All Events

A Murder Mystery Dinner Theatre: THE DANGEROUS VARIETY

  • Colloca Estate Winery 14678 W Bay Rd Fair Haven, NY 13156 United States (map)

TICKETS: $68 (Includes starter, your choice of entree, side, dessert and murder mystery live show)

Purchase Tickets
  • Location: Colloca Estate Winery Lounge

  • Date: Friday January 16, 2026

  • Time: 7:00pm-10:00pm (Cocktail hour starts at 6pm)

Experience an unforgettable evening of intrigue, entertainment, and fine dining at the stunning Colloca Estate Winery. Enjoy a delicious dinner with your choice of three entrée options while a live, interactive murder mystery unfolds all around you.

Hidden motives, suspicious characters, and unexpected twists will keep you guessing as professional actors bring the story to life. Guests are invited to question suspects, uncover clues, and collaborate to solve the mystery before the final reveal.

Set in the elegant ambiance of the winery estate, this immersive dinner theater blends engaging performances, audience participation, and a classic whodunit atmosphere. Whether you’re a seasoned detective or simply looking for a fun night out, this event promises laughter, suspense, and memorable moments.

PLOT:

Welcome to 1961 and Club Polska where tonight local radio station WSKI will be recording their popular variety show The Hunky Dory Hour! You plan to laugh it up like always but the manager of the sausage factory where you work has mysteriously died and rumors flying around Kielbasi Park say it might be the notorious Pierogi Killer! But they’re just rumors, right? You’re not worried. The Impressive Sausage Company is sending their best man and if you can’t trust a corporate fixer, who can you trust?

MENU:

MENU

STARTER:

Tossed salad ranch or Italian dressing

ENTREES:

Herb Roasted chicken with beurre Blanc Sauce

Lemon Honey Baked salmon with beurre Blanc Sauce

Vegetarian option: roasted eggplant with fire roasted red peppers with basil pesto & Balsamic reduction 

SIDE:

Rice Pilaf & peas and carrots in a herb honey butter

DESSERT

Peach cobbler with blueberry infused whipped cream  

Earlier Event: January 11
SUNDAY FUNDAY LIVE MUSIC with Cam Caruso
Later Event: January 17
Chili & Chowder Cook-off